Certain
Landscape Trees May be Naturally Doomed
by Jeanne
Rose, UC Master Gardener
Oftentimes trees were introduced to cities and towns because
they were considered well suited to the local environment. They
were used exclusively in large plantings such as streets lined
with a single species of shade tree. This practice is unlike nature,
where several species are found together and natural selection
guarantees the survival of the strongest while the weakest may
fail and die.
Other times masses of trees were used in cities and towns where
the local environment was quite different from their natural habitats.
This practice requires tender loving care of trees when conditions
become harsh.
Both of these scenarios provided ideal conditions for the evolution
of species-specific insect pests and diseases. Mass plantings
of a single species supplied a large, almost continuous food supply.
One of the most dramatic and often-cited examples of a disease
problem caused by over planting a species is Dutch Elm Disease
on American, English and Scotch Elms. This
disease has eradicated much of the elm population in the eastern
United States and it now infects some areas of California. The
Chinese Elm, which is widely planted here, is not susceptible.
Modesto Ash, once thought to be indestructible, was planted
in large quantities as street trees 30-40 years ago. It has since
been debilitated by Ash Anthracnose. Unfortunately Modesto Ash
is the most susceptible of all the ash species. Raywood Ash,
a fairly drought tolerant cultivar brought here in the early 1960s
from South Australia, became an instant success. It was trouble-free
for a few years until an occasional partial canopy death became
a serious concern to landscape managers. This problem did not
begin to appear until hundreds of thousands had been planted over
several states.
Aristocrat Pear seemed to be the perfect tree with fast
growth, a symmetrical habit, spectacular fall color, heavy bloom
in spring, and consistent success in most landscape situations.
After they were planted throughout the nation, Fireblight (a bacterial
disease) found a good ornamental host. Another potentially devastating
disease, a fungal canker, seemed to kill major limbs within two
years of the arrival of balled-and-burlap trees from Oregon nurseries.
Aleppo Pine is naturally found in areas of high ocean
influence and sandy soils in Mediterranean countries. We have
used this species in great quantities in every conceivable climate
and soil and, as a result, Western Pine Rust has become a serious
problem that sometimes kills trees. Leyland Cypress produced by
crossing cypress species native to coastal climates, but used
extensively as hedges in interior climates, is attacked by the
disease, Cypress Canker.
California Pepper Tree, actually from Peruvian stream
sides, is common throughout California. In the early 1980s the
Pepper Tree Psyllid began to infest these trees. The psyllid had
been in the United States before that, but the use of large quantities
of these trees near the coast and in severely drought-stressed
micro-climates has resulted in almost ever-present damage to pepper
trees. In the worst cases, most of the leaves drop by mid-summer
and the tree gradually starves.
Italian Alder, since the mid-1980s, has been hit by a
disease which kills the tissue at the base of the trunk when irrigation
water is sprayed on the root collar. Eventually it kills the tree.
White Alder, when used in poorly drained clay soil or
in turf with frequent shallow irrigations, becomes drought stressed.
This sets the stage for Alder Borers to lay eggs in the branches.
Under severe conditions the tree dies in three to six years.
European Olive and Chinese Pistache are affected
by the soil borne fungus, Verticillium albo-atrum. Eastern
Dogwood gets Dogwood Anthracnose disease. Coast Redwood,
which thrives in cool summer temperatures is used extensively
in the hot, dry interior of California suffers from this environment
and is also attacked by the fungus, Botryospheria ribis.
Stressed Tasmanian Blue Gum and other eucalyptus species
are attacked by the Eucalyptus Longhorn Borer. Lombardy Poplar,
genetically identical to those selected several centuries ago
in Italy, has been used inappropriately in arid areas, and is
now attacked by poplar canker and crown gall.
No tree is perfect for all situations and all trees have their
weaknesses. When choosing your trees understand that it's not
easy to predict what nature holds for their future.
August 28, 2003